This mystery began with a newspaper report of a bigamous marriage and an alleged stabbing, but became a wider investigation into a Victorian working-class family, two deceived wives, children caught in the consequences of their father’s double life, a five-year prison sentence, and the enduring social importance of marriage, respectability and family responsibility. THE NEWSPAPER…
Author: Jane
The Amelia Selina Phipps Mystery (1873): The murder of a jealous suitor
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a young woman’s murder but became an nvestigation into a Victorian farming family, a troubled courtship, jealousy and escalating violence, a possible premeditated killing, a fugitive’s escape and capture, and a petition for mercy that failed to prevent his execution. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Liverpool Weekly Mercury, 27…
The Bailey and Barry Mystery (1873): Infanticide by poisoning
This mystery began with a newspaper report of a child’s murder by poisoning but developed into a wider investigation of disputed paternity, a bitter maintenance dispute, a deceptive charitable scheme, suspicious correspondence, emerging forensic evidence, and the execution of two people convicted of the crime despite the jury’s recommendation for mercy. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Liverpool…
The John Bell Mystery (1857): The discovery of a skeleton in a field
This mystery began with the discovery of a skeleton in a Norfolk field but developed into an investigation spanning an elderly farmer’s unexplained disappearance, a substantial unpaid debt, a disputed landholding, a troubling witness account, and a coroner’s persistent promises of a breakthrough, while the identity of the remains and the ultimate outcome of the…
The Ann Foot Mystery (1845): The brutal attack on a greengrocer’s wife
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a brutal attack on a greengrocer’s wife but became an investigation into a Victorian household, a husband’s failing health, the vulnerability of a small business, and the life of a woman who survived a violent crime but was left with many questions unanswered. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE The…
The Douglas v Leon Mystery (1893): A woman without a name
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a Victorian breach-of-promise action but became a poignant investigation into a concealed identity, an alleged seduction, a financially dependent relationship, a broken promise of marriage, and a woman’s struggle to secure her future in a society where men could preserve their respectability while women risked losing their…
The Thomas Rigby Mystery (1866): A man with four wives
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a bigamy trial but became a far-reaching investigation into a transported convict’s return to England, multiple marriages under possibly assumed identities, the lives of the women he left behind, and a series of unresolved questions about his past, his movements and his ultimate fate. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE…
The Eliza Buckingham & Reuben Willis Mystery (1867): An extraordinary elopement
This mystery began with a sensational newspaper account of a married woman eloping with a young shoemaker, but became a wider investigation into a Victorian family, an unproven theft allegation, the changing fortunes of a publican and his family, and the unresolved fate of a woman who disappeared from the historical record. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE…
The Charles Head Mystery (1875): The Missing Bridegroom
This mystery began with a brief newspaper report of a bridegroom who vanished on Christmas Day, leaving his bride waiting at the church, but became a genealogical investigation that traced his family, uncovered the couple’s eventual marriage nearly three years later, and left the reasons for his disappearance an enduring Victorian mystery. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE…
The Edward and Ann Fenttiman Mystery (1863): Attempted double murder through jealousy
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a violent domestic attack and a suspicious death, but became a far-reaching investigation into a Victorian working-class family, a suspected love triangle, a possible cover-up, a mysterious disappearance under another surname, and a decades-long relationship that may have connected the widow to the very man her husband…