Skip to content

Jane Hart

Family Historian. Genealogical Researcher.

Menu
  • Home
  • The Jemima Hartford Project
    • About the Jemima Hartford project
    • Jemima Hartford Investigates Victorian Mysteries
    • The Curious Cases of Jemima Hartford and Bella Mead
    • The Memoirs of Jemima Hartford
Menu

The Bailey and Barry Mystery (1873): Infanticide by poisoning

Posted on by

This mystery began with a newspaper report of a child’s murder by poisoning but developed into a wider investigation of disputed paternity, a bitter maintenance dispute, a deceptive charitable scheme, suspicious correspondence, emerging forensic evidence, and the execution of two people convicted of the crime despite the jury’s recommendation for mercy.

THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE

Liverpool Weekly Mercury, 27 December 1873

SENTENCE OF DEATH FOR CHILD MURDER.

At the Gloucester Assizes on Tuesday, before Mr. Justice Archibald, Edwin Bailey and Anne Barry were tried, charged with wilful murder—the former as principal, and the latter as aider and abettor. The deceased was the infant daughter of a young woman at Bristol, named Jenkins, and Bailey had been adjudged its putative father. Barry had been in his employ, and, forming an acquaintance with the child’s mother, recommended Steedman’s soothing powder. Three powders were afterwards received by post, labelled “Steedman’s soothing powders,” and purporting to come from a lady named Smith, belonging to Cotham Dorcas Society. A day or two afterwards the child became ill, and a powder was given it. It died ten minutes afterwards, showing symptoms of poisoning, and the other two powders were found to contain strychnine. The handwriting of a letter sent with the powder, promising things for the child, was proved by Mr. Chabot to correspond with Bailey’s handwriting, and the paper used was similar to some in his house. The jury found both prisoners guilty, but strongly recommended them to mercy. His lordship passed sentence of death in the usual form.

THE FACTS

At first glance, this seemed to be a straightforward account of two people convicted of poisoning an infant, but what made this clipping so interesting was that it contained several research avenues beyond the murder itself: an affiliation or paternity case, a suspicious charitable connection, forensic handwriting evidence and a recommendation for mercy. We followed each of these as far as the surviving material we found would allow – mostly through reports in a variety of newspapers.

Mary Susan Jenkins

The first major breakthrough was establishing that the infant was Sarah Jenkins, daughter of Mary Susan Jenkins, usually called Susan in the accounts. Later information gives Sarah’s birth date as 23 October 1872 and her mother’s age as 17. A September 1873 newspaper report places Susan at Myrtle Cottage, Russell’s Fields, near Bristol, about three miles from the city. She had previously worked in domestic service at Clifton.

The inquest reports also explain the relationship between Susan and Edwin Bailey. Edwin was married, but he and Susan had formed an intimate relationship which resulted in Sarah’s birth. He denied paternity, and Susan obtained a magistrate’s order requiring him to contribute five shillings a week towards the child’s maintenance. This was an important discovery because it revealed a financial and personal dispute that predated the poisoning. We must be careful, however, not to assume that the maintenance dispute alone establishes Bailey’s motive.  The paternity proceedings became one of our principal research threads.

Edwin Bailey

The Central Glamorgan Gazette reports of 12 and 19 September 1873 and the Gloucestershire Chronicle of 20 September all discuss Edwin’s weekly payments. The reports establish that a magistrate had made an order and that the payments were passed through a police constable to Susan.

Our most useful additional discovery came in the longer trial report in Reynolds’s Newspaper of 28 December. It names Police-constable Critchley, who produced letters in Edwin’s handwriting, including correspondence concerning an overdue maintenance payment.

Despite searching through the newspaper reports we did not establish the date or precise court of the original proceedings. This remains one of the case’s outstanding documentary questions. We have contemporary evidence that the order existed, but not the original order itself.

One of the most intriguing elements of the case was the woman who befriended Susan and Sarah. According to the September reports, a woman began visiting Susan and appeared to take a particular interest in the baby. She brought gifts and suggested that ladies associated with the Dorcas Society wished to help the child. She reportedly visited several times a week and sometimes brought cakes and other items.

The powders arrived in a letter addressed to Susan Jenkins near the Volunteer public house. The letter purported to come from Jane Isabella Smith of Hope Cottage, Cotham, described as a visitor to the Dorcas Society. Police inquiries reportedly failed to find any such person. The visitor’s own identity was uncertain. In one account she gave her name as Ann, sometimes calling herself Louise. She reportedly evaded questions about her name and was said to have expressed an interest in adopting Sarah.

Anne Barry

An early report in the Central Glamorgan Gazette of 3 October calls the woman in custody Emma Barry, while other reports identify her as Anne or Ann Barry, and a later account calls her Mary Ann Barry. We have not resolved this variation, although the gaol register identifies the defendant as Anne Barry.

A small but revealing detail emerged from the original cutting: the letter accompanying the powder was described as “promising things for the child”. This suggests that the parcel was presented as a benevolent gift, consistent with the supposed charitable connection. Whether the promise was deliberately intended to disguise the contents is an inference, not an independently established fact.

The Dorcas Society itself is important to the social context. Such charitable associations were associated with providing clothing and practical assistance to people in need. The supposed connection made the package plausible, but the newspaper reports say the claimed sender could not be found.

The September reports allowed us to reconstruct the events more fully than the original trial summary. Three packets arrived by post, labelled as Steedman’s soothing powders. Susan gave Sarah powder from one packet, mixed with food. The child reportedly became ill, suffered convulsions and died within about ten minutes. The two remaining powders were analysed and reportedly found to contain strychnine in a vermin-killing preparation. The fuller accounts identify Mr J. Horsley, an analytical chemist from Cheltenham, as a key witness.

The evidence was not limited to the powders. Investigators compared the envelope containing the letter and packets with envelopes used for Bailey’s maintenance payments. The September reports mention similarities in the stamps and watermarks, despite the powder envelope bearing a Clifton postmark when the supposed sender was associated with Cotham.

At trial, Mr Chabot compared the handwriting on the suspicious letter with letters attributed to Bailey. The prosecution argued that the handwriting matched, despite an apparent attempt to imitate a woman’s hand.

There is, however, a significant discrepancy in the medical reporting. One September account says the post-mortem and county analyst’s examination did not reveal irritant poison in the stomach, while another describes traces of strychnine in the stomach and intestines. The December trial report also gives a version in which no traces were found in the stomach, although the analyst believed death had resulted from poison. We cannot resolve these differences from the newspaper accounts alone. The remaining powders reportedly contained strychnine, but the exact analytical findings concerning Sarah’s body require further corroboration.

The trial took place before Mr Justice Archibald on 23 December 1873.  The prosecution presented the circumstances of the poisoning, the relationship between the defendants and Susan, the maintenance correspondence, the chemical evidence and the handwriting comparisons.

The defence challenged the prosecution’s interpretation of the evidence. Bailey’s counsel questioned the handwriting evidence and the inference that Bailey had deliberately planned the murder. Barry’s counsel argued that she had been employed to investigate the child’s paternity and denied that she had participated in the poisoning.

The jury found both defendants guilty of wilful murder and strongly recommended mercy. Mr Justice Archibald nevertheless passed the death sentences.

A post-execution report in the Central Glamorgan Gazette of 16 January 1874, headed “Triple Execution at Gloucester” reports that Edwin Bailey and Ann Barry were executed alongside Charles Edward Butt at Gloucester Gaol at eight o’clock on Monday morning, 12 January 1874. Butt had been convicted of a separate murder.

The report also claims that Bailey and Barry confessed on the Sunday before their executions. Bailey reportedly made a full disclosure to the prison chaplain but asked him not to reveal the details. The newspaper attributed his crime to his atheistic beliefs, but we have not found the confession itself or independent evidence establishing that interpretation.

This investigation has uncovered several wider social historical themes.

  • Illegitimacy and financial responsibility: The affiliation order demonstrates the legal route by which a mother could seek maintenance from a putative father. Susan’s case also shows that such arrangements could become entangled with personal relationships and criminal investigations.
  • Domestic service and class: Susan’s employment in service and Barry’s work as a charwoman and shop cleaner help explain how people in different households came into contact.
  • Charitable benevolence: The supposed Dorcas Society connection exploited the social expectation that charitable women might provide assistance to a child in need.
  • Postal and forensic evidence: Handwriting, paper, stamps, watermarks and chemical analysis all featured in the prosecution. The case illustrates the importance—and limitations—of the forensic methods used in the 1870s.
  • Capital punishment and mercy: Despite the jury’s strong recommendation, Bailey and Barry were executed. The subsequent reporting of confessions and religious beliefs shows how newspapers framed the final hours of condemned prisoners.

CONCLUSION

The strongest part of our findings is the convergence of contemporary newspaper reports with the Gloucester Gaol and committal records. Together, they establish a coherent account of the investigation, trial, convictions and executions.

The most valuable result is not that every mystery has been solved, but that we can now separate the established documentary trail from the claims and questions that remain open.

Bailey and Barry were executed on the same day as Charles Edward Butt, whose separate murder case appears in the next Mystery case. Their individual stories should remain distinct, but that shared date gives us a documented link between the cases.

THE SUMMARY IMAGE

Jemima’s Victorian Mysteries

Latest

1890-1899

The Alice Chard Mystery (1899): A Deceptive Marriage

The Catherine Riordan and Dr. Bright Mystery (1896): The shooting of an Oxford don

The Catherine Malenoir Mystery (1895): Melodrama in the court room

The Albert and Jane Dore Mystery (1894): A marriage in name only

The Douglas v Leon Mystery (1893): A woman without a name

The Sarah Ann Love Mystery (1893): A woman who blinded her husband with vitriol

1880-1889

The Edward Jones & Elizabeth Elliott Mystery (1889): The bridegroom who walked away

The Violet Jane Donaldson Mystery (1888): The disappearance of a clerk

The Jane Sharples Mystery (1887): An unusual drowning

The Thomas Joseph Thompson Mystery (1884): Two deceived women

The Ann Carter Mystery (1883): A dead baby found following the death of his mother

The Esther Pay Mystery (1882): The Murder of a Child

The Margaret Radford Mystery (1880): Burnt to death on Christmas Day

The Mary Wheeler Mystery (1880): an abandoned infant at Fishponds, Bristol

The Louth Infant Death Mystery (1880): a still-born child is buried in a cemetery

1870-1879

The Elizabeth Mary Edwards Mystery (1879): A seven-week disappearance

The Reuben Lively Mystery (1878): The attempted poisoning of his sister

The Richard Evans Mystery (1876): A matter of colour

The Edward Holmes Mystery (1876): a suspicious death by poisoning

The Charles Head Mystery (1875): The Missing Bridegroom

The Minnie Jane Goodson Mystery (1874): a little girl is drowned in suspicious circumstances

The Bailey and Barry Mystery (1873): Infanticide by poisoning

The Amelia Selina Phipps Mystery (1873): The murder of a jealous suitor

The George Frederick (Fritz) Weippert Mystery (1872): The Missing Commercial Traveller

The George and Annie Augusta Loe Mystery (1870): The fictitious child

The Thomas Morton Mystery (1870): The dead child in a parcel

1860-1869

The Charles Henry Jelley Mystery (1868): A fatal elopement

The Eliza Buckingham & Reuben Willis Mystery (1867): An extraordinary elopement

The Rose Charles Mystery (1867): The Reverend and the Servant

The Thomas Rigby Mystery (1866): A man with four wives

The Samuel and Mary Eastwood Mystery (1865): The elopement of a man with his aunt

The Edward and Ann Fenttiman Mystery (1863): Attempted double murder through jealousy

The William Sears Mystery (1862): the foolish fellow of Harpenden

The Sarah Eliza Scholes Mystery (1860): Double Murder at Irlams-o-th’-Height

The Anne Grace Mystery (1860): The suicide of a publican’s wife

1850-1859

The John Bell Mystery (1857): The discovery of a skeleton in a field

The Rosamond Ongley Mystery (1857): A young girl is drowned while fleeing her mother

The Jane Angus Mystery (1853): The wife who was not acknowledged

The Thomas Wardleworth Mystery (1850): A scandal in Bury

The John and Anne Curtis Mystery (1850): The wife who became a husband

The Martha Joachim Mystery (1850): The death of an eccentric lady

The Elizabeth and Ann Biggs Mystery (1850): A pregnant woman starves to death

1840-1849

The Lady Pynn Mystery (1849): A Christmas tragedy in Cheltenham

The Elizabeth Stanton Mystery (1849): The drowning of a young woman at Fencott Bridge

The Adelaide Lister and Maurice Drummond Mystery (1847): An aristocratic elopement

The William Mystery (1846): a tragic accident at South Shields

The Ann Foot Mystery (1845): The brutal attack on a greengrocer’s wife

The Memoirs of Jemima Hartford

Part I: My Childhood in Kent (1855-1877)
written in 1881

Part II: My Marriage to Edward (1877-1881)
written in 1881

Part III: My Life and Work (1881-1901):
written in 1901

Part IV: My Life with Beatrice (1901-1912)
written in 1912

Part V: My Life in a Changing World (1913-1923) written in 1923

©2026 Jane Hart | Built using WordPress and Responsive Blogily theme by Superb
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT