This mystery began with a newspaper account of a young mariner killed in a boating accident but became an investigation into a mistaken identity, a prominent maritime family, generations of shipowners and pilots, and a newspaper story whose most intriguing claims proved impossible to verify. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE The Birmingham Journal, 18 July 1846 MELANCHOLY…
Latest Mysteries
The Mary Wheeler Mystery (1880): An abandoned infant at Fishponds, Bristol
This mystery began with the discovery of a two-week-old baby, left alone in a field at Fishponds on a November night. It became an investigation into the identity of the young mother, her family circumstances, the treatment she received from the authorities, and the fate of a child whose life appears to have begun in…
The Edward Holmes Mystery (1876): A suspicious death by poisoning
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a suspected poisoning but became a far-reaching investigation into a Victorian family, a troubled marriage, a possible suicide, an elusive young woman, a mysterious male companion, and the hidden private lives that remained tantalisingly beyond the reach of the police. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Birmingham Evening Mail, 17…
The Louth Infant Death Mystery (1880): A still-born child is buried in a cemetery
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a suspicious infant death but developed into a wider investigation of a Victorian family, a concealed birth, a grandmother’s prosecution, a fractured marriage, and the unanswered question of whether a baby who lived for just fourteen hours had been deliberately killed. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE The Heywood Advertiser,…
The Rose Charles Mystery (1867): The Reverend and the Servant
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a young servant accused of stealing from her employer, but developed into an investigation of an alleged assault, a clergyman’s reputation, the contrasting reactions of the public, and the subsequent lives of the two people at its centre. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Newcastle Weekly Chronicle, 4 January 1868…
The Minnie Jane Goodson Mystery (1874): A little girl is drowned in suspicious circumstances
This mystery began with the suspicious drowning of a six-year-old girl but developed into an investigation of a Victorian family, a bereaved child’s upbringing, a stepmother under suspicion, an inconclusive coroner’s verdict, and a haunting poem that kept whispers of wrongdoing alive long after her burial. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Taunton Courier, 2 September 1874 SUSPICIOUS…
The Charles Henry Jelley Mystery (1868): A fatal elopement
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a scandalous elopement and a sudden death, but became a wider investigation into a Victorian businessman, an abandoned wife and family, financial ruin, an unidentified young woman, and the resilience of those left behind. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE Birmingham Journal, 10 October 1868 FATAL TERMINATION TO AN ELOPEMENT….
The Adelaide Lister and Maurice Drummond Mystery (1847): An aristocratic elopement
This mystery began with a dramatic newspaper story about an aristocratic young woman who eloped with her suitor to France, only to be brought back by his brothers. But as the investigation developed, it became much more than a romantic escapade. It opened a window onto two influential families, the political world surrounding the Prime…
The George Frederick (Fritz) Weippert Mystery (1872): The Missing Commercial Traveller
This mystery began with a newspaper account of a missing commercial traveller accused of impersonating a famous composer, but became a far-reaching investigation into a Victorian musical dynasty, royal connections, financial hardship, marital discord, a troubled family left dependent on the workhouse, a proposed second marriage, and a disappearance that remains unexplained despite extensive research….
The Esther Pay Mystery (1882): The Murder of a Child
This mystery began with the a newspaper account of a murdered child but became a far-reaching investigation into a Victorian family, a suspected murder, an adulterous relationship, a contested police procedure, and a divorce that continued to attract attention long after the criminal trial had ended. THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE The Citizen, 1 February 1882 CHARGE…