Skip to content

Jane Hart

Family Historian. Genealogical Researcher.

Menu
  • Home
  • The Jemima Hartford Project
    • About the Jemima Hartford project
    • Jemima Hartford Investigates Victorian Mysteries
    • The Curious Cases of Jemima Hartford and Bella Mead
    • The Memoirs of Jemima Hartford
Menu

The Sarah Eliza Scholes Mystery (1860): Double Murder at Irlams-o-th'-Height

Posted on by

This mystery began with a newspaper account of a double murder in a Victorian family home but became a deeper investigation into epilepsy, domestic violence, conflicting witness testimony, a disputed claim of self-defence, and a woman whose mental condition prevented her from standing trial and led to nine years in an asylum.

THE NEWSPAPER ARTICLE

Ormskirk Advertiser, 19 April 1860

DOUBLE MURDER AT PENDLEBURY – On Thursday night, William Scholes, aged seventy-five, and William Edward Scholes, aged forty-one, were murdered in the house in which they lived in Irlams-o-th’-Height, about a mile from the Pendleton toll-bar. In the same house lived two children of the former – Joseph, aged thirty-four, and Sarah, aged thirty, the latter a strongly-built woman, said to be subject to fits, and at times very violent. The former states that when proceeding home through Salford, about seven o’clock on Thursday night, he was seized with a fit and taken to the police-office. On arriving at home there was no one below but he heard a noise like someone knocking in his sister’s bedroom. Before going to bed he went to his sister’s room door, but could not get in. During the night he was awakened several times by a noise in his sister’s bedroom, and went to the door but still found it fast. About six o’clock in the morning he went out to get some water and met a young woman, whom he told about the noise, and induced her to accompany him into the house. Having broken open the door of his sister’s room with a hatchet, he beheld a horrible spectacle. On one side of the bed was his father murdered, the upper portion of his body resting upon that of his son William, who had also been murdered. His sister lay upon the bed in the same room with her clothes on. Joseph Scholes and his sister were afterwards apprehended. It was a general opinion that the daughter was in one of her violent moods on Thursday night, before Joseph returned home; that the father and brother went into her bedroom to endeavour to keep her quiet; and whilst there during the night she had attacked and strangled them both. The neighbours, and those who live in the house adjourning, say that quarrels were of frequent occurrence in the family, and on the night referred to the people next door were awakened in consequence of the noise which was heard, and the wife suggested to her husband that they might be killing one another. The most remarkable part of the affair is that Joseph Scholes should have been in the house whilst the murders were being committed, and should have not heard sufficient noise to cause him to give an alarm. Sarah Eliza Scholes was taken before the magistrates on Friday, and it appeared that when arrested she alleged that, having been seized with one of her fits, her father and brother, who were annoyed by her cries, had come upstairs and commenced to beat her, and that, in self-defence, she took a stick, struck her brother, and throttled him, and then served her father in the same way. Her story is partially corroborated by marks on her body.

THE FACTS

This newspaper article told an extraordinary story, and its reconstruction of the event was that Sarah Eliza Scholes had gone into one of her violent states and that her father and brother had gone into her bedroom to restrain or quiet her, and she had attacked them. But there was immediately a major mystery, Joseph was apparently in the house during the murders. During the night he heard noises from Sarah’s locked bedroom but did not enter, and it wasn’t until the next day that he broke down Sarah’s bedroom door and discovered the two bodies. That was the starting mystery – how could Joseph have been in the house, heard noises and yet apparently not realise that his father and brother were being killed?

We first reconstructed the Scholes family The census evidence turned out to be remarkably good. In 1841 the family was together at Irlams of the Height: William Scholes aged 55, a farmer, was with his wife, Sarah, aged 55 and their children William Edward, aged 20, a letterpress printer. George aged 15, a mechanic, Thomas, aged 15, Joseph, aged 14,  Sarah, aged 11 and Jane aged 2.  In 1851, living at Scholes Corner, Pendlebury, we found: Sarah Scholes, aged 64, provisions dealer’s wife, Joseph, aged 24, a printer/compositor pressman, Sarah E, aged 21 and Mary Griffiths. William senior and William Edward were absent from this household.

Then we found the burial of Sarah Scholes in December 1856, the wife of William Scholes, who had died aged 69 in Pendlebury. So Sarah Eliza’s mother had died about three years before the murders.

Subsequent newspaper reports gave us much more detail about the murder scene: There had clearly been a violent struggle. The evidence included: scratches and injuries on Sarah, bruising to her arms and legs, scratches around her neck as well as a walking stick, penknives, blood, and injuries to both men.

William senior was found with a closed clasp knife in his hand. William Edward was found on the bed, with serious injuries. The medical evidence reported at the time said that William senior died from suffocation/strangulation, while the early report described William Edward as having suffered a fatal stab wound involving the eye and brain. However, a later September 1860 newspaper retrospectively described William Edward’s injury differently, as a stab wound to the throat. That discrepancy remains unresolved.

Joseph’s story became increasingly interesting. His evidence was one of the most intriguing aspects of the case. He said he had suffered a fit while returning home and had been taken to the police station because initially the police thought he was drunk. Later, when he returned home, he heard Sarah moving about upstairs. During the night he heard noises from her room. At one point he apparently heard Sarah calling “Help, help!”, and another account records something resembling “I’m choking.” Yet he did not enter the room. This was one of the things that made the original newspaper report so suspicious of the circumstances.

But we subsequently discovered something important about Joseph himself. He was admitted to Prestwich Lunatic Asylum on 11 February 1865 and died there on 6 May 1873. So Joseph too had a significant history of mental disturbance/fits – probably epilepsy. That doesn’t prove anything about what he knew or did on the night of the murders, but it certainly makes his behaviour in April 1860 more understandable as a subject for further investigation.

Maria Turner was the mysterious “young woman” who helped Joseph break into his sister’s  In fact the Manchester Guardian account of the incident identified her as aged only nine. She had seen Sarah and her brother, William Edward, sitting quietly together by the fire at about 9 p.m. That is a surprisingly important little detail because it gives us an approximate last-known peaceful moment between Sarah and her brother. But it also makes the original description of the witness as a “young woman” rather misleading!

Sarah eventually gave an extraordinary account. This was perhaps the biggest development from the original clipping. While being held at the Salford workhouse on Thursday afternoon, she gave a voluntary statement to Police Constable Dixon. Her account was broadly: she went upstairs to her bedroom;  her father and brother came into the room; they got onto her bed and began to beat her; she took up the stick in self-defence; she struck William Edward; she throttled him;  she then did the same to her father;  and then  her father fell on top of her brother. This was not simply a denial. It was effectively an admission that she had killed both men, coupled with a claim of self-defence and lack of control during a fit. There was some corroboration for the allegation that she had been assaulted: witnesses observed numerous bruises and other marks on Sarah’s body.

But Sarah then claimed she remembered nothing This is where the case became considerably more complicated. When brought before the magistrates, Sarah repeatedly said: “I don’t remember anything at all about it.” She appeared to accept some of the evidence by nodding, but continued to say she had no memory of the events. Later she said: “I have no remembrance whatever until they spoke to me the following morning, when they were dead.” So we have three things existing simultaneously: 1: She admitted killing them. 2: She claimed she had acted in self-defence, and 3: She claimed she could not remember doing it. That is one of the central mysteries of the case.

The medical evidence was crucial. The prison surgeon, Frederick Merton, examined Sarah. He considered her to show signs of insanity and epilepsy. He described her as powerful and muscular and said that when under the influence of a fit she could be extremely difficult and dangerous to interfere with. He also observed bruising, scratches and other injuries.

Joseph confirmed that their father sometimes struck Sarah with his walking stick, although he said this was intended to frighten or control her rather than seriously injure her. Joseph also said their father normally entered Sarah’s bedroom only when she was having a fit. That provides an important possible context for the fatal encounter: Father and brother may genuinely have gone into Sarah’s room because she was having a fit — exactly as Sarah herself claimed. What happened once they were in the room is much less certain.

The legal position became extremely unusual. Sarah was committed for trial, but the charges were not reported consistently. The April 1860 newspaper evidence says she was committed for the murder of her father and the  manslaughter of her brother. A later newspaper report in September 1860 stated that she had been committed for the murders of both.

Then came the crucial discovery. A September 1860 newspaper report explained why Sarah had disappeared from the Liverpool trial reports. When her case reached the Liverpool Grand Jury, it was determined that her mental condition was such that she was unable to plead. Consequently, the case was not taken into court – it was remanded until the next assizes, and  Sarah was sent to Prestwich Lunatic Asylum meanwhile. This finally explained why we could find no conventional trial.

Then we found Sarah’s Prestwich record.  Findmypast’s transcription gives:

Sarah Eliza Scholes. 
Admitted:  27 April 1860
Patient no. 1139.
Death: 6 October 1869. 

It also contains the intriguing note: “Manslaughter charge father.” That doesn’t agree neatly with the April 1860 newspaper evidence, which described the charge as murder of the father and manslaughter of the brother. So we have deliberately left that discrepancy unresolved.

It now appears that the Lancashire Archives catalogue actually has an individual casebook record for Sarah. Most importantly, the catalogue says the material is open and available to view at their Archives room. So we now know that Sarah’s actual asylum casebook record survives. Obtaining a copy of this  will help us to understand the circumstances of her admission, her epilepsy/fits, and whether she remained under any form of criminal detention.

There was apparently no subsequent trial in the newspapers in 1860 or 1861 nor in the Liverpool Assize records. Sarah remained at Prestwich Asylum, and  as we have seen, she eventually died on 6 October 1869, aged 39. She was buried at St Mary the Virgin, Prestwich, 3 days later, on 9 October 1869, and recorded as

Sarah Eliza Scholes, daughter of William Scholes, aged 39, abode Prestwich Asylum, formerly of Pendlebury.

So, as far as we can currently establish, she spent approximately nine years in Prestwich Asylum after the murders.

Epilepsy, Violence and the Victorian Understanding of Mental Illness

This case provides a striking glimpse into the Victorian understanding of epilepsy and its relationship with insanity. In the 1860s epilepsy was still poorly understood, and the boundaries between a physical seizure disorder, mental illness and supposed moral or behavioural abnormality were far less clearly drawn than they are today. Modern historical research describes the period from about 1860 onwards as the beginning of the “modern” era of epilepsy, but also notes that epilepsy was widely associated with mental deficiency, abnormality and even particular personality traits. It carried considerable social stigma and was often concealed rather than openly discussed.

The Scholes case illustrates this attitude particularly vividly. Sarah was described as being subject to fits, and the newspapers portrayed her as becoming extremely violent when affected by them. The prison surgeon, Frederick Merton, believed that she was epileptic and that during a fit she could be “very fearful to be interfered with”. Her family evidently regarded her fits as sufficiently serious that her father and brother would enter her bedroom to assist her. Yet the same behaviour could also be interpreted as dangerous insanity. The distinction between an involuntary manifestation of illness and deliberate violence was therefore blurred. This helps explain the extraordinary situation in which Sarah could apparently admit killing both men, yet the authorities subsequently concluded that her mental state was such that she was unable to plead.

Her eventual confinement at Prestwich also demonstrates how epilepsy could become entangled with the Victorian asylum system. People suffering from epilepsy were not necessarily treated separately from those regarded as mentally ill: nineteenth-century institutions frequently grouped epileptic patients with people described as lunatics, idiots or otherwise of unsound mind. Sarah’s nine years at Prestwich therefore tell us something about the way Victorian society dealt with people whose behaviour was considered both medically abnormal and potentially dangerous. The tragedy at Irlams-o’-th’-Height was not simply a story about a woman who killed two members of her family; it was also a case in which Victorian medicine, law and society struggled to decide where epilepsy ended and insanity, responsibility and dangerousness began. That uncertainty is perhaps the most revealing social-history aspect of the whole case.

CONCLUSION

What began as a newspaper clipping about a rather bizarre double murder has turned into a remarkably well-documented story.
We can now follow Sarah from her family home
through epileptic/violent episodes to the terrible night of 12 April 1860, which resulted in two deaths. Then her extraordinary admission
and claims of self-defence and amnesia, and the medical evidence of epilepsy and unsoundness of mind, which meant that although she was committed
to the next Assizes, she went into the Prestwich Asylum on 27 April 1860, which resulted in her inability to plead. Then nine years late she died in the asylum in 1869, aged 39.

THE SUMMARY IMAGE

 

Jemima’s Victorian Mysteries

Latest

1890-1899

The Alice Chard Mystery (1899): A Deceptive Marriage

The Catherine Riordan and Dr. Bright Mystery (1896): The shooting of an Oxford don

The Catherine Malenoir Mystery (1895): Melodrama in the court room

The Albert and Jane Dore Mystery (1894): A marriage in name only

The Douglas v Leon Mystery (1893): A woman without a name

The Sarah Ann Love Mystery (1893): A woman who blinded her husband with vitriol

1880-1889

The Edward Jones & Elizabeth Elliott Mystery (1889): The bridegroom who walked away

The Violet Jane Donaldson Mystery (1888): The disappearance of a clerk

The Jane Sharples Mystery (1887): An unusual drowning

The Thomas Joseph Thompson Mystery (1884): Two deceived women

The Ann Carter Mystery (1883): A dead baby found following the death of his mother

The Esther Pay Mystery (1882): The Murder of a Child

The Margaret Radford Mystery (1880): Burnt to death on Christmas Day

The Mary Wheeler Mystery (1880): an abandoned infant at Fishponds, Bristol

The Louth Infant Death Mystery (1880): a still-born child is buried in a cemetery

1870-1879

The Elizabeth Mary Edwards Mystery (1879): A seven-week disappearance

The Reuben Lively Mystery (1878): The attempted poisoning of his sister

The Richard Evans Mystery (1876): A matter of colour

The Edward Holmes Mystery (1876): a suspicious death by poisoning

The Charles Head Mystery (1875): The Missing Bridegroom

The Minnie Jane Goodson Mystery (1874): a little girl is drowned in suspicious circumstances

The Bailey and Barry Mystery (1873): Infanticide by poisoning

The Amelia Selina Phipps Mystery (1873): The murder of a jealous suitor

The George Frederick (Fritz) Weippert Mystery (1872): The Missing Commercial Traveller

The George and Annie Augusta Loe Mystery (1870): The fictitious child

The Thomas Morton Mystery (1870): The dead child in a parcel

1860-1869

The Charles Henry Jelley Mystery (1868): A fatal elopement

The Eliza Buckingham & Reuben Willis Mystery (1867): An extraordinary elopement

The Rose Charles Mystery (1867): The Reverend and the Servant

The Thomas Rigby Mystery (1866): A man with four wives

The Samuel and Mary Eastwood Mystery (1865): The elopement of a man with his aunt

The Edward and Ann Fenttiman Mystery (1863): Attempted double murder through jealousy

The William Sears Mystery (1862): the foolish fellow of Harpenden

The Sarah Eliza Scholes Mystery (1860): Double Murder at Irlams-o-th’-Height

The Anne Grace Mystery (1860): The suicide of a publican’s wife

1850-1859

The John Bell Mystery (1857): The discovery of a skeleton in a field

The Rosamond Ongley Mystery (1857): A young girl is drowned while fleeing her mother

The Jane Angus Mystery (1853): The wife who was not acknowledged

The Thomas Wardleworth Mystery (1850): A scandal in Bury

The John and Anne Curtis Mystery (1850): The wife who became a husband

The Martha Joachim Mystery (1850): The death of an eccentric lady

The Elizabeth and Ann Biggs Mystery (1850): A pregnant woman starves to death

1840-1849

The Lady Pynn Mystery (1849): A Christmas tragedy in Cheltenham

The Elizabeth Stanton Mystery (1849): The drowning of a young woman at Fencott Bridge

The Adelaide Lister and Maurice Drummond Mystery (1847): An aristocratic elopement

The William Mystery (1846): a tragic accident at South Shields

The Ann Foot Mystery (1845): The brutal attack on a greengrocer’s wife

The Memoirs of Jemima Hartford

Part I: My Childhood in Kent (1855-1877)
written in 1881

Part II: My Marriage to Edward (1877-1881)
written in 1881

Part III: My Life and Work (1881-1901):
written in 1901

Part IV: My Life with Beatrice (1901-1912)
written in 1912

Part V: My Life in a Changing World (1913-1923) written in 1923

©2026 Jane Hart | Built using WordPress and Responsive Blogily theme by Superb
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT